White and Black River Valley Railway (a.k.a. Cotton Plant Railroad)

Body Font
Font choices apply to languages written in the Latin alphabet. This translation uses the standard font.
Body Text Size

aka: Cotton Plant Railroad

Even before the Civil War, a railroad was proposed with the idea of connecting east-central Arkansas with Jacksonport (Jackson County), which at that time was a notable riverboat town at the major bend of the White River in northeastern Arkansas near Newport (Jackson County). In 1857, the Arkansas General Assembly amended the Arkansas Midland Railroad’s charter to allow it to build to Jacksonport. After the Civil War, the Helena and Northwestern Railroad was proposed in the 1870s to be built from Helena (Phillips County) northwesterly to Jacksonport. Jacksonport’s importance waned, however, after the Cairo and Fulton bypassed Jacksonport by going through Newport in the early 1870s. But within a decade, activity began that would lead to an east Arkansas–Jacksonport connection.

A Modest Beginning
An early 1878 article stated that the Memphis and Little Rock Railroad (M&LR) was going to create a branch from Brinkley (Monroe County), on its main line, up to Cotton Plant (Woodruff County). Later that year, a narrow-gauge pike was being built toward Cotton Plant. However, this short line was underway to support other interests of two Memphis, Tennessee, denizens, Major William Black and John Gunn, who were developing timber, manufacturing, and other commercial enterprises in the area. As 1879 ended, service extended up to Saulsburg (Monroe County), where construction had paused a couple of miles shy of Cotton Plant. Projections at the time said the railroad would extend to Augusta (Woodruff County), and people generally referred to it as the “Cotton Plant” or the “Brinkley and Cotton Plant” railroad.

The owners chartered their creation as the Cotton Plant Railroad in May 1881. The first passenger service listed in the Official Guide appeared in November 1881, with a schedule dated September 1. It mentioned connections at Cotton Plant with stages for Augusta. Travel time for the ten or so miles between Brinkley and Cotton Plant was approximately two hours.

The Concept Expands
The Cotton Plant officers soon had bigger ideas. They incorporated the Batesville and Brinkley Railroad Company (B&B) in late 1881 to connect the namesake cities. This was followed by newspapers announcing B&B stock offerings at Batesville (Independence County), Jacksonport, Newport, Brinkley, and Little Rock (Pulaski County). One such announcement concluded with “if you want a railroad, show how much you want it by subscribing liberally.” A stockholders’ meeting was scheduled at Batesville in mid-January 1882. By this time, Black was listed as residing in Brinkley and as a director of the Texas and St. Louis (T&SL), the three-foot-gauge road then being constructed across Arkansas and passing through Brinkley.

Early 1882 saw the new company moving quickly on three fronts. First, Southern Construction Company was incorporated and awarded a contract. There was some overlap in the officers of the construction company and of the B&B. Mention was made that the company had purchased the “Jacksonport and Newport railroad, with all its franchises.” Second, B&B acquired the Cotton Plant Railroad. And third, survey work marched forward. In late winter 1882, the Batesville Guard announced the arrival of James Martin, B&B chief engineer, on the steamer Alberta. With a survey now completed between Cotton Plant and the Black River, Martin was tasked with identifying a route between the Black River and Batesville. A prime option was said to be a “river route…along the base of the river hills…to Paroquet Bluff”—near the community of Paroquet (Independence County)—on the west bank of the Black. On May 19, 1882, the route map, profile, and field notes were filed with the Secretary of State in Little Rock.

Up Against Jay Gould
In July, the Guard reported that Jay Gould—owner of the St. Louis, Iron Mountain and Southern Railroad (SLIM&S), a key part of the Missouri Pacific system—was prepared to construct a branch from its main line near Newport up to Batesville. Batesville clamored for a rail connection and the benefits it would bring, and did not particularly care who built it. Recognizing that the financial strength of Jay Gould was likely to accomplish the goal sooner, the newspaper called on B&B to “get out of the way and give him a route.”

But B&B was not going to roll over in the face of Gould’s advances. Late July saw a suit filed in chancery court contending that since B&B had a franchise to construct a line between Jacksonport and Batesville and the proposed Iron Mountain branch was within ten miles of it, the Iron Mountain should be stopped. The Iron Mountain contended that as a successor to the Cairo and Fulton charter, it had a right to build the branch. In mid-August, the court refused to issue a restraining order. The ruling determined that the prohibition against duplicating another railroad’s route applied to each route taken as an overall whole, not just a small portion of a route. Since, for the most part, B&B and SLIM&S routes were not duplicates, Iron Mountain could therefore proceed.

In early September, the Batesville Guard reported that upon hearing that B&B would sell its right-of-way for $3,000, citizens raised the amount and proffered it to the B&B, only to learn that the railroad had changed its mind about the sale. A fall appeal to the Arkansas Supreme Court for a writ of mandamus to compel the chancellor to restrain the Iron Mountain was turned down. The Iron Mountain would begin service to Batesville in 1883.

The Batesville and Brinkley may not have been able to stop the Iron Mountain from constructing up the White River valley into Batesville, but it did get its revenge. Approaching Batesville, the rugged terrain closed in on the river valley, leaving only one viable railroad route, which the B&B had already claimed. Blocked from taking an easy way to Batesville, the Iron Mountain had to swing into rugged terrain west of Newark (Independence County) and proceed by way of Sulphur Rock (Independence County), thus increasing both construction costs and ongoing train operating expenses.

Changes and Challenges
On other fronts, the Cotton Plant Railroad had been built to a three-and-a-half-foot gauge, the dimension of choice at that time for other narrow gauge lines east of Brinkley. As the Texas and St. Louis (T&SL) was nearing completion of its three-foot-gauge railroad from northeastern Texas across Arkansas to Cairo, Illinois, the B&B and the Arkansas Midland entered into a traffic agreement with T&SL, and in the last half of 1882 converted to three-foot gauge to facilitate interline car interchanges. But after the T&SL went into receivership and was reorganized as the St. Louis, Arkansas and Texas Railway (SLA&T), the SLA&T saw the need to convert to standard gauge, much of which was accomplished in late 1886. The B&B followed suit in 1888.

The 1883 Poor’s manual reported twenty-five miles of line in operation, with thirty-three cars (two for passengers). Also, there were two locomotives. Among the seven directors were three from Brinkley, one from Jacksonport, and one from Newport. The principal office was at Brinkley.

The tracks reached Jacksonport in 1886, passing a half dozen miles east of Augusta. An 1887 announcement said tracks were to proceed twenty-seven miles north to Black Rock (Lawrence County). Other rumors had it headed to Portia (Lawrence County) or Hardy (Sharp County). (The new rail line between Springfield, Missouri, and Memphis went through all three towns.) These northward extensions did not come to pass.

Meanwhile, papers for incorporation of the Augusta and Southeastern Railway Company were filed in August 1888. The purported intent of this Lone Grove–based enterprise was to build a sixteen-mile line from a point on the B&B to Augusta. It completed three miles of line from Coates (Woodruff County) to Watkins (Woodruff County) in 1888, and another three miles to Lone Grove by mid-1889. The Batesville and Brinkley owned a controlling interest in the company. (Lone Grove may have been at or near Gregory in Woodruff County.)

Even a small railroad like the B&B could not escape the hazards of railroad operation in the 1800s. In summer 1888, the locomotive of a southbound passenger train derailed when it struck a tree that had fallen across the tracks. The resulting boiler explosion scalded the engineer to death.

Yet Another Name
In 1890, the B&B became the White and Black River Valley Railway Company (W&BRV). Included in the new company was the six-mile Augusta and Southeastern, running from its connection at Coates (renamed Wiville) west across the Cache River to Gregory. Among extensions still touted were to build northward from Newport to a connection with the Frisco, and southeasterly from Brinkley to Helena.

In July 1898, Congress approved a bill allowing the White and Black River Valley Railway Co. to construct a bridge across the Black River somewhere north of its confluence with the White at Jacksonport. The bridge was to have a “drawspan” to preserve navigation on the Black. Since the government wished to keep the number of bridges crossing navigable streams to a minimum, the act granted any other railroad an equal right to use the bridge, upon “payment of a reasonable compensation.” But the railroad never did construct that extension.

Under Control of Large Companies
In 1900, the Choctaw, Oklahoma and Gulf (CO&G), which was in the process of creating a route from Memphis through Little Rock to the Texas Panhandle, leased the W&BRV for eighty years. The CO&G had previously absorbed what was now the Little Rock and Memphis, so it connected with the W&BRV at Brinkley. The initial lease required payment of $25,000 per year, which then increased to $30,000, or five percent of the outstanding bond amount. Soon thereafter, the Chicago, Rock Island and Pacific, commonly known as the Rock Island, acquired and leased the CO&G.

A 1903 map under the name of Frisco subsidiary St. Louis, Memphis and Southeastern showed a proposed extension along the Black River valley southward from Pocahontas (Randolph County) to Newport. If built, this would have created an end-to-end connection with W&BRV. Rock Island and Frisco were allied railroads in the early 1900s.

The W&BRV would also own about seven miles of other track and share 0.1 miles of track at Brinkley with the Iron Mountain.

Through the 1920s, railroads across the country were feeling economic losses due to improvements to motor vehicles and the roads they drove on. On the heels of that came the Great Depression. Railroads responded by cutting back both service and entire lines, but many, including the Rock Island, would still go into bankruptcy in the 1930s.

In July 1927, the Rock Island requested permission to jettison 3.5 miles of line between Newport and Jacksonport. There had been no operation on the line since it had been damaged by an April flood. (A map from this era appears to show the track between Newport and Jacksonport atop a levee on the east side of the White River.) In years past, traffic had been secured from riverboats, but now there was “practically no freight” on the segment.

In mid-1928, the Interstate Commerce Commission (ICC) allowed the railroad to cease operation on the track between Newport and Jacksonport, but it did not allow the railroad to abandon those miles. The Rock Island made a request in the mid-1930s to abandon operation on the remaining part, but the ICC only approved stopping service on the Gregory branch. In bankruptcy proceedings in 1934, the Rock Island disaffirmed the lease, essentially offering to give the W&BRV back to its owners. Upon this notice, Rock Island no longer had to pay the annual rent.

In 1940, the trustees for the Chicago, Rock Island and Pacific Railroad and its subsidiaries filed with the ICC to abandon the line. During the hearings, it was stated that the line had initially been constructed to harvest timber in the corridor, but most of the area had been cut over and was redeveloping as highly productive agricultural land. Mixed trains (i.e., combined passenger and freight service) were making a round trip three times per week, with any passengers riding in the caboose. In the last half of the 1930s, annual losses incurred ranged from $8,500 to over $25,000. Maintenance on the line had been minimal, so trains were limited to fifteen miles per hour. An interesting side note to the proceedings was the desire of rice mill owners at nearby Carlisle (Lonoke County) and Stuttgart (Arkansas County), served by the Rock Island, for the Rock Island to retain service on the W&BRV, in order to receive single-line rates for shipments to their mills.

Counsel for W&BRV stated that they represented all of the stockholders and many of the bondholders, being unable to locate about a quarter of the bondholders. W&BRV owners stated that, as a stand-alone operation, the line was worthless except for a $119,000 salvage value. In early 1941, approval was granted to abandon the fifty-six miles from Brinkley through Newport to Jacksonport, and the six-mile Gregory branch. The Rock Island said it was interested in buying a short W&BRV segment at Brinkley to maintain service to a cotton compress and a lumberyard.

For additional information:
Interstate Commerce Commission Reports, Vol. 244 (Finance Reports). Washington DC: Government Printing Office, 1941, pp. 51–59.

“Railway Projects.” Railroad World 16, no. 4 (January 25, 1890): 90.

Statutes at Large of the United States of America from March 1898 to March 1899, Vol. 30. Washington DC: Government Printing Office, 1899, pp. 650–651.

J. L. Gattis
University of Arkansas, Fayetteville

Comments

No comments on this entry yet.