calsfoundation@cals.org
Orin E. Hendrickson (Murder of)
The 1983 killing of Orin E. Hendrickson was a murder-for-hire that rocked the town of Arkadelphia (Clark County) after it was alleged that the crime was orchestrated by two students from Ouachita Baptist University (OBU), possibly acting under the influence of a woman who had been employed by the university as a “dorm mom” and a department secretary. Ultimately, four individuals were shown to be involved in the murder, but only two—one student and Hendrickson’s wife—were imprisoned for it, leaving many to wonder if justice had truly been served.
Orin Edwin Hendrickson was a native of Eureka, Kansas, born on November 27, 1943, to Ole and Elizabeth Hendrickson. Hendrickson was a 1967 graduate of Pittsburg State University in Kansas, with a degree in industrial arts. In February 1965, he married Patricia Ann Mendenhall in Eureka. Patricia was the eldest daughter of Archie B. and Franciel Mendenhall and was born on September 30, 1943, in Latimer County, Oklahoma. By 1950, Patricia and her family lived in Eureka, where her father was employed as a motor company mechanic.
Following Orin and Patricia’s marriage, the couple resided in Louisiana and Virginia before settling in the Arkadelphia area in 1971. In 1973, the Hendricksons had their son Bradley Edwin. In Clark County, Orin Hendrickson worked as a quality supervisor for the Southern Pine Inspection Bureau, which provided quality assurance standards to the softwood lumber industry. He was a member and deacon at Second Baptist Church in Arkadelphia and a member of the Hoo-Hoo International, a fraternal order of the forest products industry headquartered in Gurdon (Clark County). He also assisted with the community’s Little League program.
On the evening of Thursday, March 10, 1983, Patricia Hendrickson returned to the couple’s home in the community of Gum Springs (Clark County) from an outing to Hot Springs (Garland County) with her friend Norma Foster. Foster had been employed at OBU as a “dorm mom” in Ernest Bailey Hall and as a secretary in the Athletics Department. At 7:20 p.m., Foster phoned the Clark County Sheriff’s Office to report that Orin Hendrickson had been shot. Police arrived to find him dead in the kitchen from apparent gunshot wounds to the chest. The assailant appeared to have entered through a bathroom window. The home showed signs of being searched, but nothing of value was determined to be missing. The Sheriff’s Office, with assistance from the Arkadelphia Police Department and Arkansas State Police in Hope (Hempstead County) and Hot Springs, mounted a manhunt in the area for an alleged suspect, a Black male wearing a green army jacket and carrying a shotgun. The Arkansas Department of Corrections brought in a team of bloodhounds to help comb the area. Finding no leads, authorities called off the manhunt at 2:00 a.m. on March 11.
Hendrickson’s autopsy confirmed that his death was caused by two close-range 12-gauge shotgun blasts, and his time of death was estimated at around 11:30 a.m. Don Wesson, Clark County criminal investigator, confirmed that Hendrickson had left the International Paper Plant in Gurdon around 11:05 a.m., as was his habit on Thursdays. Arkansas Medical Examiner Fahmy Malak stated that the shotgun pellets recovered from Hendrickson’s body were too mutilated for a positive identification. Law enforcement speculated that Hendrickson had unsuspectingly surprised a burglary in process, leading to the shooting.
Over eight months passed before any arrests were made in Hendrickson’s murder, but on November 21, 1983, three suspects were taken into custody—Patricia Hendrickson, Norma Foster, and former OBU student Howard Daniel Vagi of Plainsboro, New Jersey. Vagi had been a sophomore at OBU during the 1982–83 school year but had not returned to Arkansas in the fall of 1983. The three were apprehended following a lead provided by Vagi’s uncle, to whom Vagi had confessed the crime, including his role as the “trigger man.” According to Clark County Prosecuting Attorney William H. “Dub” Arnold, Foster arranged the contract killing, acting as the middleman between Hendrickson and Vagi, who was paid to carry out the killing. The alleged motive was financial gain. Patricia Hendrickson reportedly collected $140,000 of life insurance following her husband’s death.
A second OBU student involved in arranging the killing, Mark Yarbrough of El Dorado (Union County), was never charged. This was in exchange for his testimony, which included information on the supposed whereabouts of the murder weapon. Based on information provided by Yarbrough, Arkansas State Police divers and Union County Civil Defense workers dragged Lake Calion (Union County) and the Ouachita River in late November, but they found no murder weapon.
According to testimony given by Yarbrough in a 1985 retrial, Foster contacted him to ask if he knew of anyone who could “get rid of someone.” Yarbrough talked to his friend Howard Vagi, who agreed to murder Orin Hendrickson for $16,000. Through Yarbrough, Foster provided Vagi with a map and key to the Hendricksons’ house. Yarbrough also testified that Patricia Hendrickson gave him money to purchase a gun. He and Vagi traveled to a pawnshop in Benton (Saline County), where they purchased the murder weapon.
The four collaborators originally agreed upon Thursday, March 3 as the date on which Hendrickson would be killed. Yarbrough drove Vagi to the area, dropped him off, and returned to Arkadelphia. Vagi had second thoughts and did not go through with the killing, which Yarbrough testified angered Foster and Hendrickson since they had taken some valuables from the home to later establish robbery as the motive. One week later, however, Vagi returned by himself to the home and shot Hendrickson. After discarding the murder weapon and his clothing, Vagi returned to the OBU campus, where he sought out Yarbrough in a chemistry class and confirmed that Hendrickson was dead.
Patricia Hendrickson, Norma Foster, and Howard Vagi were tried separately for the murder. Vagi pleaded guilty to first-degree murder on January 4, 1984. Judge J. Hugh Lookadoo accepted the plea and sentenced Vagi to life in prison. In 1988, the Arkansas Supreme Court denied Vagi’s request to have his sentence reduced to ten years. Vagi maintained that he had agreed to a plea bargain by which, prosecutors assured him, he would be out of prison after ten years. In 1997, Governor Mike Huckabee denied a commutation request submitted by Vagi, and he died in prison in Arkansas on December 5, 2011, at the age of forty-nine.
The cases against Foster and Hendrickson proved more challenging to try. Both women pleaded not guilty to the charge of capital felony murder. Held without bond since her arrest in November, Hendrickson underwent thirty days of psychiatric evaluation at the Arkansas State Hospital, while Foster was held in the Hot Spring County jail. In late January, Judge Lookadoo issued a continuance until April to allow defense attorneys time to prepare for trial.
At Foster’s trial in early April 1984, jurors heard what the state alleged to be her taped confession. In the recording, Foster told law enforcement, “I mentioned to Pat that I might know someone that might go about killing someone—she asked me to talk to that person.” Foster also recalled arriving at the Hendrickson home on the evening of the shooting. As they pulled into the driveway, she said, “It was already in my mind that Orin was dead before we went into the house.” Hendrickson was called as a witness during Foster’s trial but pleaded the Fifth Amendment. After deliberating for less than two hours, the jury returned a guilty verdict for Foster on the charge of first-degree murder and recommended a sentence of life in prison.
Patricia Hendrickson’s trial began the following day, April 11. Travis Mathis, attorney for Hendrickson, argued that Foster was the “evil mind” behind the shooting and had orchestrated the killing out of jealousy because she was in love with Patricia. The following day, the jury returned a guilty verdict against Hendrickson and recommended the death sentence. On April 14, Judge Lookadoo sentenced Hendrickson to death by lethal injection, making her the first woman to face execution in Arkansas in over forty years. Hendrickson was sent to the Arkansas Department of Corrections Women’s Unit at Pine Bluff (Jefferson County), while Foster was released on $100,000 bond.
Both convictions were appealed and overturned on the grounds that authorities had improperly questioned the women in March 1983. Hendrickson maintained that she had invoked, but was denied, her right to counsel. Both women were retried in December 1985. During Foster’s retrial, she placed the blame for orchestrating the killing on Hendrickson. Foster’s taped confession from March 1983 was disallowed from being entered into evidence during the retrial. After fourteen hours of deliberation, the jury remained deadlocked, forcing Judge Lookadoo to declare a mistrial in Foster’s case. At her third trial in April 1986, Foster was reconvicted and again sentenced to life in prison. In December 1986, however, the Arkansas Supreme Court dismissed Foster’s murder conviction on appeal, saying they had found nothing in the record of Foster’s trial to corroborate the testimony of Yarbrough and Vagi.
Foster remained free for the remainder of her life following the Arkansas Supreme Court’s refusal to grant prosecution a rehearing in February 1987, a ruling upheld by the U.S. Supreme Court five months later. Foster returned to her home state of Iowa, where she lived until her death on May 17, 2023, at the age of eighty-eight.
In Hendrickson’s second trial, held in December 1985, she was again found guilty of capital murder. The Arkansas Supreme Court upheld her conviction in November 1986 and again in 2000. In October 1986, Hendrickson was confined to the women’s unit at Tucker Penitentiary. She was transferred to the McPherson Unit northeast of Newport (Jackson County) in November 2003 and remained there until her death on February 8, 2023, at the age of eighty.
For his part in the murder, Mark Yarbrough was never prosecuted. In 1985, he moved to Arizona and later graduated with a BS in chemistry from Grand Canyon University. For twenty-three-years, he worked as a chemist for Arizona Public Service at the Palo Verde Nuclear and Redhawk power plants. He died on August 31, 2010, at the age of forty-eight.
For additional information:
“Conviction in Slaying Dismissed.” Arkansas Gazette, December 16, 1986, pp. 1A, 11A.
“Ex-Dorm Mother on Trial for Third Time for Murder.” Baxter Bulletin, April 22, 1986, p. 3.
“Jury Convicts Woman; Widow’s Trial Begins.” Batesville Guard, April 11, 1984, p. 7.
“Mistrial Declared in Slaying Case at Arkadelphia.” Arkansas Gazette, December 12, 1985, p. 20A.
Nelson, Rex. “Crime Comes to the County.” Daily Siftings Herald [Arkadelphia, AR], March 11, 1983, p. 2.
Page, D. W. “Wife, Students Charged in Hendrickson Case.” Daily Siftings Herald, November 21, 1983, p. 1.
“Plea Accepted in Slaying; Life Term Set.” Arkansas Gazette, January 5, 1984, p. 10.
“Retrials to Begin Next Week for Women Accused of Murder of Arkadelphia Man.” Batesville Guard, December 5, 1985, p. 9.
“Woman, 40, Is Sentenced to Death.” Arkansas Gazette, April 14, 1984, pp. 1A, 9A.
Lisa Speer
Ouachita Baptist University
Comments
No comments on this entry yet.