Harrison Race Riots of 1905 and 1909

aka: Charles Stinnett (Execution of)

Though nowhere near as murderous as other race riots across the state, the Harrison Race Riots of 1905 and 1909 drove all but one African American from Harrison (Boone County), creating by violence an all-white community similar to other such “sundown towns” in northern and western Arkansas. With the headquarters of the Knights of the Ku Klux Klan (KKK) located nearby, Harrison has retained the legacy of its ethnic cleansing, in terms of demographics and reputation, through the twentieth century and into the twenty-first.

The U.S. Census of 1900 revealed a Black community in Harrison of 115 people out of 1,501 residents. This constituted a vibrant community that, despite its poverty, had a cohesive culture and deep roots. By all accounts, relations between the white and Black communities were relatively friendly and stable before the riots (dependent, of course, upon the expected subservience of Black citizens to white people). The catalyst for change was the St. Louis and North Arkansas Railroad (later the Missouri and North Arkansas Railroad), which was built through Harrison in 1901, exciting the populace with visions of prosperity. But the railroad went bankrupt on July 1, 1905, creating hardship for the townsfolk and the railroad workers who had moved to the area. The completion of the rival Missouri Pacific line, which ran through Omaha (Boone County), fifteen miles north of Harrison, left many more unemployed, both Black and white. Some found their way into Harrison, where their lack of deference (they had been independent and used to being paid well for their work) inflamed the ire of Harrison’s white residents.

The enmity that Harrison felt for its Black population came to a head on October 2, 1905, when a white mob stormed the jail and took two Black prisoners—one of whom had been charged two days earlier with breaking into Dr. John J. Johnson’s residence—along with several others and transported them outside city limits. There, they whipped their captives and ordered them to leave. The mob then went on a rampage through Harrison’s Black community. Numbering about thirty, they burned down homes, shot out windows, and ordered all African Americans to vacate the town that night. Many did, fleeing to places such as Fayetteville (Washington County) and Eureka Springs (Carroll County) or to Missouri. In the following days, the people who had stayed were attacked and harassed. On October 7, 1905, J. E. Hibdon, member of a posse, shot and killed Black railroad worker George Richards at the Omaha railroad camp.

The civic power structure of Harrison likely approved of the mob action. According to Jacqueline Froelich and David Zimmerman, “Diligent research has failed to reveal any records of actions taken by law enforcement officers or any other local officials to protect Harrison’s African American community at any time preceding, during, or after the attacks.” But John Henry Rogers and James Kent Barnes—judge of the Western District of Arkansas and district attorney, respectively—sought to use a grand jury already scheduled to be empaneled to bring the perpetrators of mob violence to justice. Their task was rendered impossible by the disappearance of so many potential Black witnesses and by the reluctance of the white jury to seek indictments against their fellow men, many of whom were reputedly of good standing in the community.

The remnants of the Black community in Harrison lived a tenuous existence until 1909, when Harrison’s transformation into an all-white town was made complete by yet another riot. The ostensible catalyst for this second round of violence was the January 18, 1909, arrest of Charles Stinnett on the charge of raping a white woman. To stem the potential for mob violence, Judge B. B. Hudgins made provisions for a speedy trial. At his trial on January 21, twenty-four-year-old Stinnett testified that he intended to rob the sixty-one-year-old Lovett but that he did not assault her. The jury was out for four hours, with one holdout eventually joining the other eleven jurors in convicting him. He was sentenced to hang on February 26, 1909.

Upon hearing news that Lovett was gravely ill after the trial, a lynch mob formed and proceeded toward the Harrison jail; Stinnett was transported to Marshall (Searcy County). But the continuing presence of the mob resulted in another mass exodus of Black citizens from Harrison. Most left on the night of January 28, 1909, following some of the same roads their predecessors took four years earlier. Only one Black townsperson, Alecta Caledonia Melvina Smith, known as “Aunt Vine,” remained. The property of those who left was quickly declared forfeit.

Governor George Donaghey stayed the execution of Stinnett for thirty days on February 22 since “some who gave testimony at the trial…have since expressed themselves as doubtful of the verdict,” while Stinnett’s attorney sought time to seek commutation to a life sentence. Stinnett’s mother came to Boone County from Okmulgee in the Indian Territory (present-day Oklahoma) and circulated petitions seeking his commutation, gathering “about 800 names of prominent citizens of Boone County…among them the names of nine members of the jury.” Donaghey, however, declined to intervene and set March 24, 1909, as the date for the execution.

The condemned man was to be hanged at 1:00 p.m. on March 24, but “somebody had given Stinnett whiskey and at 1 o’clock he was too drunk to stand,” the Arkansas Gazette reported. Having sobered up sufficiently by 4:00 p.m., he was taken to the gallows, which were concealed by a canvas cover to shield the execution from a crowd that had gathered. He said on the scaffold that “he was guilty of an attempt at an assault,” and in a statement he had signed earlier confessed that he had intended to rob Lovett and pulled a knife to scare her into not raising an alarm. “I ask all who hope for a sinner’s return to pray for me,” the statement said. “If I had told the truth at my trial I would have come clear of death.” When the trap door opened, “his neck was not broken and he died of strangulation, but without a struggle.” He was declared dead fifteen minutes later, and his body was sent to his mother in Okmulgee, the passage paid by funds raised through public subscription.

Racial violence in Boone County may have led African Americans in neighboring counties to flee the area. Census records for Carroll and Madison counties show that, between 1900 and 1910, the Black population dropped steeply. Whether this was because of a desire to escape the area’s climate of hostility, or whether other, unreported incidents of racial violence may have driven the Black population out, remains unknown.

As Harrison’s white residents tried to erase the Black community in their town, they apparently also tried to erase the historical record of the events in question. The files of the local newspaper, the Harrison Daily Times, contain gaps coinciding with the dates of the riots, and though records exist, including transcripts of testimony, for most of the other cases heard by Judge Rogers’s 1905 grand jury, only one handwritten note with the dates of the investigation’s beginning and end remains extant. But the cumulative historical record makes the Harrison Race Riots an undeniable instance of racial violence, in the manner of what was occurring elsewhere in the nation—as the increasing disenfranchisement of African Americans made violence toward them a political expediency—and in the world, which was experiencing a new penchant for ethnic cleansing.

For additional information:
“Charles Stinnett Is Found Guilty.” Arkansas Gazette, January 23, 1909, p. 2.

“Charlie Stinnett Hangs at Harrison.” Arkansas Gazette, March 25, 1909, p. 1.

“Execution Is Stayed.” Fort Smith Times, February 23, 1909, p. 2.

“For Commutation of Chas. Stinnett.” Arkansas Democrat, March 14, 1909, p. 2.

Froelich, Jacqueline, and David Zimmerman. “Total Eclipse: The Destruction of the African American Community of Harrison, Arkansas, in 1905 and 1909.” Arkansas Historical Quarterly 58 (Summer 1999): 133–159.

Morgan, Gordon. Black Hillbillies of the Arkansas Ozarks. Fayetteville: University of Arkansas Department of Sociology, 1973.

“A Negro Exodus.” Springdale News, February 3, 1909, p. 1.

Rea, Ralph. Boone County and its People. Van Buren, AR: Press-Argus, 1955.

Russell, Jessie Lewis. Behind These Ozark Hills. New York: Hobson Book Press, 1947.

“Stinnett Must Be Executed.” Arkansas Democrat, March 18, 1909, p. 3.

Watkins, Loren. “Some History of Boone County, Arkansas.” Boone County Historian 7, no. 1 (1984): 282–286.

Staff of the CALS Encyclopedia of Arkansas


No comments on this entry yet.